Trump, Bannon Push Back Against McMaster’s Proposed Afghanistan Troop Surge

President Donald Trump has refused to sign off on a proposal by National Security Advisor H.R. McMaster to increase the U.S. military presence in Afghanistan, according to a report by Politico‘s Susan Glasser.

According to Glasser, a “heated debate” arose, with McMaster and Secretary of Defense James Mattis on one side, and the President and his Chief Strategist Steve Bannon on the other, which was described by senior officials present as a “s*** show”. The President was reportedly “dissatisfied” with the proposal, which resulted in him “sending it back to his national security team demanding more work”. He later told reporters, “I want to find out why we’ve been [in Afghanistan] for 17 years.”

McMaster’s main foreign policy focus is now said to be increased troop numbers in Afghanistan and a commitment to four more years of significant U.S. military presence in Afghanistan as a prerequisite for starting talks with the various militant groups involved in the country’s complex civil war.

McMaster’s plan was initially opposed by Mattis and Secretary of State Rex Tillerson, who believed such a proposal would not receive Trump’s support, with Tillerson stating “I’m not selling this to the president”.  However, the plan was subsequently modified to garner Mattis’ backing for it.

Bannon proposed an alternative plan involving Blackwater’s Erik Prince, a paramilitary figure known for his strong support for Trump during last year’s presidential campaign, and the brother of Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos. This plan, which Mattis believed “goes too far” in the privatization of the United States’ military engagements, would involve replacing the existing U.S. presence in Afghanistan with small numbers of elite mercenaries.

report last week by Politico‘s Eliana Johnson and Annie Karni suggested that Bannon has removed himself from many policy discussions within the White House in a effort to preserve his job, but notably has remained engaged in the debate over military intervention, “warning against deeper U.S. involvement” in Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria. The report suggests that the most influential staffer within the White House’s nationalist camp is now Senior Advisor Stephen Miller, the writer of Trump’s iconic Warsaw speech, who has taken care to maintain a good personal relationship with aides such as McMaster and Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner whom Bannon had previously clashed with.


  1. It is a grave error for Trump to turn over foreign conflicts to his generals. They may be great warriors but they will not bring us peace.

  2. We can’t turn Afghanistan into Switzerland. The best we can do is figure out how to leave it but in a state where it won’t create or support terrorism.
    Make a deal with the Taliban if needed – They originally all but eliminated the Opium Poppy and we gave them a half-billion for their efforts, but we refused to talk to them after 9/11 since we wanted regime change, and to punish, and the northern alliance narco-terrorists were considered a better alternative.
    Trump should deal there, and in what is left of Iraq.

  3. I do hope Trump and Bannon succeed on this one. Our troops must get out of Afghanistan and stay out. The poppy fields will do fine without our activity! Actually, for that matter, get out of the Middle East mess entirely. The no-win wars should cease. The generals have no clue regarding a goal other than continue any war and support the military industrial complex and the corporate manufacturers and suppliers of weapons.

Comments are closed.

Latest from News

Thanks for visiting our site! Stay in touch with us by subscribing to our newsletter. You will receive all of our latest updates, articles, endorsements, interviews, and videos direct to your inbox.